Back in college, my roommate and I would find ourselves on a few Saturday afternoons lounging around trying to figure out what to eat. Then inevitably one of us would say, “You know what would be great right now? A cheesesteak.” An hour later, we’d be making the two hour drive from DC to Philadelphia to chow down on a cheesesteak from Ishkabibble’s or Jim’s on South Street. They were always great. Who knew that I should have also added getting some fish tacos on our short trip.
I was in Philadelphia a few weeks ago to shoot an engagement session. My client, another food lover asked me if there was anything in particular that I wanted to eat while I was in town. Well, well… I told him about Taco Pescado and he said he knew one of the best restaurants in Philadelphia for fish tacos and I had to try it. I’m starting to like that this happens now. The great thing about this blog is getting to meet other people that love fish tacos as much as I do. It makes it easier to discover new ones.
In addition to his suggestion, I was able to cram in two other restaurants during my trip. It was quite a feat since I was only in the city for about 36 hours. I was impressed with what Philadelphia had to over and I had a hard time choosing a favorite. Here are the contenders:
1. Distrito – After the shoot, my clients and I headed to Distrito for brunch to sample his favorite fish tacos. I spent the first 10 minutes being distracted by my failing phone. Yes, I still have a Blackberry. Yes, I know this is wild. After the fish tacos came, I finally started taking in the ambience of the place. The best way to describe it is upscale kitsch. Slightly charming, slightly screaming of pink. The presentation of the fish tacos were beautiful. A perfect balance of color. More places should use red cabbage. Distrito’s tacos have a fried, plantain-encrusted mahi mahi with a chipotle remoulade, red cabbage, and avocado. They’re tiny, but delicious.

2. Rouge – I was staying at the Latham Hotel in Rittenhouse Square which was around the corner from Rogue. Can I just say that I love Rittenhouse Square? Somehow in all of my trips to Philly, I’d never been to this part of town and I’ve been missing out. Anyway, I walked into Rogue as they were opening for lunch. The restaurant is reminiscent of a Parisian boutique and a seat at the center, circular bar, offered a great view of Rittenhouse Square. As I ordered my fish tacos (tilapia, avocado, romaine, mango salsa), Steve, one of the regulars sat beside me. As I chatted with him, I became really intrigued by the restaurant. I’d never heard of the place so I didn’t realize that this fine dining spot was a hotbed of who’s who in Philadelphia. It was interesting to say the least. I found the journalist in me coming out and wanted to dive in further into what this place was and who it was for. I can’t explain the vibe that it has, but an article from Philly Mag in 2006 perfectly nailed it. When the tacos came, I realized that this was my first time trying fish tacos in a fine dining establishment. They were really good. The fish was cooked perfectly and didn’t have that weird aftertaste that tilapia has sometimes and the mango complemented the fish perfectly. They weren’t the best fish tacos I’ve had, especially at the price point, but there was something special about eating them there. A noteworthy fish taco experience.

3. Cucina Zapata – On my way out of town, I made a quick stop at Cucina Zapata. When I saw the line for this popular Thai-Mexican fusion food truck, I was just sure I was going to miss my bus. Anyway, I felt like I had to do it. They had a Cap’n Crunch fish taco that brought back all types of warm and fuzzy feelings from my childhood from the name alone. When I stepped up and made my order, the guy said, “Shannon, right?” Puzzled, I asked how did you know? Turns out I’d tweeted about the place the day before and they saw it and remembered. Nice touch…point. It turns out that the fish tacos, were actually a burrito, but he was kind enough to give it to me in taco form. Another point. When the fish tacos were ready, I grabbed them along with my bags and schlepped my way to the Megabus, careful not to tilt the container. After I arrived, I had a bite of the Captain Crunch encrusted taco with avocado, tomatoes, lettuce, red cabbage and a secret sauce of sorts inside flour tortillas. I was pleased with the taste. There’s only a hint of sweetness from the cereal, so it doesn’t overpower the fish. Very good flavor. It did need some heat to it. I realized he didn’t hear me say spicy, so I missed out on the sriracha. Slight bummer.

So now that we have the best restaurants in Philadelphia for fish tacos, who takes the crown? While I loved every experience, if I’m judging strictly on taste, Distrito wins. I really enjoyed all the places I visited, but my client was right, Distrito has a great fish taco. They actually rank very high in my best tacos I’ve ever eaten list. I had a really great Taco Pescado experience in Philadelphia though. Reminds me that I need to get back to the city more often.